SuperGeekery.com

Ad Agencies Have a Relationship Problem

2008-04-29T01:10:00Z

I’ve never seen the play I Love You, You’re Perfect, Now Change, but its title has come to mind during more than a couple recent conversations when the topic of traditional advertising agencies and their clients comes up. If I were to write a play about the ad business today, I’d call it I Like You Sometimes, You Cost Too Much For What You Deliver, And If You Change, I’m Leaving You. Clearly my title is not as catchy as the original, but I think it sums up the situation; fundamentally, most advertising agencies have a relationship problem with their clients. (I say most, not all. If you’ve got examples of good agency/client relationships, please send me an email. Better yet, post a comment about it.)

Clients who have existing relationships with agencies are seldom willing to accept radically different solutions from those agencies because doing so breaks the rules that govern the relationship. When agencies break the rules by behaving in unexpected ways, i.e. delivering radical solutions rather than the expected ones, at a minimum they are not taken seriously and in some case they are punished for it.

Unfortunately, that’s just human behavior.

Think about any person in your life with whom you’ve had a long relationship and now imagine that over the course of a few days they’ve radically changed somehow and are acting in an unexpected way. What type of change? To make it interesting, let’s say they’ve suddenly converted to some new religion which requires serious evangelizing or maybe they’ve discovered they’ve got to have a sex change to fully express who they are. Maybe it’s both. When that person suddenly starts breaking the rules you have both abided by in your relationship, you become wary of that person. You might even think they’d lost their marbles.

Ad agencies haven’t lost their marbles though. Agencies get a lot of flack for not understanding the state of the digital world, but I’ve been inside a lot of them and there are some really smart people there. Putting their new media understanding to practical application has been difficult because delivering solutions based on that knowledge isn’t what’s expected of them. Their current clients see the agency as delivering a particular thing which is probably what attracted them to the agency in the first place, be it TV ads, media buys, banner ads, Flash web sites, or whatever. Clients expect to keep receiving that same exact thing from that relationship. Agencies might believe the thing they deliver is “great ideas to solve marketing problems” but clients are just people and people tend to remember the concrete deliverable, a TV spot or an online banner campaign with a landing page, rather than the intangible, an idea or concept that led to an execution (i.e. that damn TV ad).

What’s an ad agency with an identity crisis to do? If you think about this as a real-world relationship, the answer is pretty clear. That doesn’t make for an easy solution to follow through with though.

Let’s think about you and your friend again who’ve had that long-standing relationship. This time, it’s not your friend who’s suddenly started acting in unexpected ways; it’s you who has realized something’s changed in your life and to be true to your beliefs you need to start expressing yourself in a completely new way. How to do you handle this old relationship? What do you do?

Option #1:
The give-into-the-fear approach. The easiest short-term choice is to choose not to tell your friend that things have changed. You can go on acting the way around him as you always have but your focus on maintaining that relationship will wain and the truth will start to show through lack of attention. The longer this goes on the more you just want to get as far away from this relationship as possible.

Option #2:
The one-day-at-a-time approach. Don’t get too hasty. You can take gradual path towards revealing the new you to your old friend. Maybe you’re just going through a phase anyway, right? You can drop hits about new outlook on life and hope your friend is receptive but you can still go out to the same old hangouts and still do a lot of the familiar things. In the short term, things are going to be fine. You need to be careful to not backslide into your old ways though. It’s easy to confuse slow progress with no progress.

Option #3:
The we’ve-got-to-talk approach. This is where you drop the bomb and see how strong your relationship really is. You are either going to make or break this relationship. If it goes all wrong, this whole thing could be history. You and your friend part and go forward following your own paths. If it goes well though, the benefits could be tremendous for both of you.

When it comes to the business relationships, what options do agencies chose? Small steps or no steps at all seem like a risky way to move forward in the digital space which is known for moving very fast.

An ad agency that goes for option #1 or #2 should work overtime at forging new client relationships that let them be the new-media-savvy shop they really are deep down. Of course, if they choose option #3 with at least one current client and the meeting goes well, they’re much more likely to have tangible experience with a long-standing client that will benefit them with getting those new clients who share their point of view.

A Murakami Grows in Brooklyn

2008-04-23T21:02:01Z

Today I took an afternoon trek to the Brooklyn Museum for the Takashi Murakami show. It’s an exhibit that was originally put together by the Museum of Contemporary Art (MOCA) in LA. The New York Times calls Mr. Murakami the Japanese version of Andy Warhol in their review of the show. There is a Louis Vuitton shop right in the middle of the exhibit selling extremely expensive bags. When my friend and I priced out a small bag at $1600, we decided it was more a stunt than a true shopping experience.

There are many incredible pieces to the exhibit. Near the beginning there are 3 sculptures of eroticized anime-style female cyborgs. The 3 life-size sculptures show the transformation of this anime woman from winged techy nymph to rocket ship. I wasn’t able to photograph personally, it but have found a photo of it (click the thumbnail for a larger view) from the Gothamist’s preview of the show.

The exhibit is one of the most enjoyable times I’ve spent at a museum in recent memory. I dare you to go and not come out in a better mood than you went in. And by the way, at first glance this might seem like an ideal show for kids, but be warned, there’s some pretty explicit sexual themes in the work.

When the show was at the MOCA, the museum produced a series of videos about the exhibit. There are 8 videos in all. The first is before the jump. To view the rest, just click through to the rest of the article.

Lastly, the Oval Buddha was not in the Brooklyn Museum exhibit, but it’s part of the YouTube series from MOCA. I’ve read that it’s on display in Manhattan at 56th Street and Madison. Enjoy!

Talking with Colmeia TV About Agencies, Advertising Failure & Geekery

2008-04-14T14:34:01Z

Last week I had the pleasure of meeting Eduardo Camargo from Colmeia. He, Vini Reis (a friend and former colleague of mine) and I had a great time hanging out and talking about the things that excite a geeks like us: technology, innovation, marketing and more. Eduardo taped it and put part of our conversation on Colmeia’s vlog which you can see below. You can also follow Eduardo and Vini on Twitter.

colmeia na gringa | @NYC | episodio 2 from eduardo camargo on Vimeo.

Digital Evangelists Roundtable, Round 1

2008-04-14T01:45:02Z

This past Thursday night I was lucky to be part of group of people got together to talk about the state of digital advertising, technology and what the future holds for marketing in the digital age. John Haake, from Eyeblaster, was the host at ValBella.

The evening wasn’t presented as an Eyeblaster event though. No one talked about their technology or what they were selling. It was just a discussion amongst people who care about making progress in the way marketing is done in the ever-changing digital space. We’re in the middle of a full-on collision of forces shaping how products are created, designed, built, marketed and sold and each person at our little gathering brought a unique perspective on a piece of the action.

This first night’s gathering we spent a fair amount of time talking about what’s going right and wrong in the spending of media dollars. Although it may sound obvious, one comment really stood out to me on how the digital world of media differs from the “traditional” way media was bought. Before the digital revolution when a TV spot or magazine ad ran that marked the end of the media buyer’s job. The planning had happened; the buying had happened. What little work that was left was to make sure your spot ran or that the magazine reproduced the color of your ad properly.

In the digital age though, the moment your interactive pieces go live only marks the end of one stage of a multi-stage process. The beginning of the job was the initial planning and buying, similar to what was done traditionally, but because of the ability of digital to adapt to what you’re finding out in real time, there is a huge amount of work left to do to get the most out of your media spend. Ideally, that doesn’t mean just the media plan is adapted over time, but the creative executions as well. This concept is pretty easy to understand in terms of an online banner campaign where banners are rotated over time based on what’s being clicked on and how a banner’s click through rate changes the longer it is in market, but there is a much bigger scope of information that can be evaluated on a large digital buy and the complexity can lead to many opportunities being missed along the way. I’d love to explore this optimization topic more next time from the point of view of media, account, creative, and brand planning.

The word “widget” was mentioned approximately 112 times, but I lost count somewhere in the mid-60s. Why was “widget” talked about so much? It’s a buzz word of the moment that’s started to stick with people across the marketing industry. The term has stuck, but not a definition of what it means is pretty vague. One person’s widget is another person’s gadget is another person’s embedded video. Whatever you think it is, to get the most out of the widget concept means agreeing on a what you or your client is talking about. Again, here’s another topic that I think we can explore further.

We’ve got the initial introductory meeting done. I think we’ve done well by getting to know each other a bit. We’re collectively trying to come to a decision on what to do next. I think “optimization” and “widgets” will definitely be part of the next meeting. It should be fun.

See Ben Weisman, who invited me to the evening (thanks, Ben!), has also written about the night on his blog here. Check it out. Also thanks to Ben and Gefen Lamdan for the photos used above.

Who was there? Amy Auerbach from PHD, David Berkowitz from Marketer’s Studio, Matt Enos from Tribal DDB, Amaya Garbayo from Mindshare, John Haake from Eyeblaster, Liza Hausman from Gigya, Alex Jorissen from Eyeblaster, Lindsey Kollross from MEC, Gefen Lamdan from Eyeblaster, John Morton (me) from johnfmorton.com LLC, Linda Payson from Avenue A | Razorfish, David Pogue from The New York Timess, Adam Romero from Agency.com, Adam Shlachter from MEC, Troels Smit from Eyeblaster, Doug Stivers from Beyond Interactive, Persia Tatar from Media Post, and Ben Weisman from Eyeblaster, Digitas, Bucky Ben Consulting and Dogmatic. (Yes, Ben is a busy guy!).

How To Make a Mix Tape In the Digital Age

2008-03-30T22:25:59Z

I love music and used to spend hours making the perfect mix tape to share with my friends. I didn’t realize how much I missed it. If you’ve got some MP3’s, some time, and some friends you want to make a mix for, check out muxtape.com. If you make a mix tape, send me a link.

BTW, Music companies, if you are listening, don’t kill this site. If someone can make the act of listening and sharing music this fun, I’m sure there are ways you can live with it. Just add a ”buy this track” button next to each song and it’s doing your job for you.

The Elephant in the Room at PSFK Conference New York

2008-03-28T20:47:01Z

Yesterday I attended PSFK Conference New York. My overriding impression of the conference was that we marketing professionals are all struggling to define what we’re doing. There were loads of smart people presenting their perspective on the web 2.0 world and none of them were wrong, although they often openly contradicted each other.

At one point Rob Kallin, founder of Etsy.com, the online craft market place, and Andrew Hoppin from NASA seemed to be trading jabs about the laugh-ability or viability of Second Life as a useful collaboration tool. Although I personally dislike Second Life due to what I consider a poor user interface, it is valuable to some people. Andrew Hoppin gave the example of people living on the space station being able to share the same virtual space with people back on Earth is a good thing. He’s right! Second Life may be the best existing tool available for that at present.

Noelle Weaver, from SS+K, kicked off the “Social Media” session by asking the attendees how many of them have tried to erase a social media profile in the past few weeks. In a room full of Web 2.0 thinkers, a surprising number of hands went up, roughly 15% by my estimate. A room full of social-media-types erasing profiles? Another interesting contradiction.

By the end of the presentations the Indian proverb about the blind men touching an elephant and then describing what an the animal was like based on their impression. The morale of that story is that basically that people who are too insistent that their personal view is right are ignorant. That wasn’t the case at the PSFK event though. It was about sharing viewpoints and trying to figure out what this gigantic creature in our midst really is. If we keep describing what we feel this thing is and share those thoughts, we’re going to figure it out.

Looking back on the day, Grant McCracken pin-pointed the key to success for all of us in this business with a concept he called “brute noticing.” (Slides from his presentation available here.) It’s a term I really love. He said our clients depend on us “seeing things early and clearly, on grasping new patterns.” Since this creature is growing and changing so fast, no one person can figure it all out alone.

Follow up: PSFK has started posting some of the videos shot that day on YouTube. Below is one where Steve Rubel says the most newsbite-friendly line of the whole conference, “The Web site is dead.” He does admit saying he likes “saying things are dead.” It made for a great line at the conference. For more video from the conference, click here.

Two More Links To Make Your Internet Experience Complete

2008-03-23T14:44:02Z

Opinions are like blogs, everybody’s got one. But some blogs are better than others, so I thought I’d share a couple that you might not know about. The first is focused on the ad business, the second is a thoughtful perspective on our culture. Both are worth checking out.

Ad Aged—Will Madison Avenue Become Detroit? by George Tannenbaum, as you might guess, is the advertising focused blog. I worked for George for a couple years and he’s filled with insightful and entertaining observations on the state of the advertising industry plus the state of the rest of the world. Luckily, he now shares them with the blogosphere. Check out “Daily dumbness update” for a good example of his take on the state of advertising. You can tap directly into his POV on Ad Aged every morning.

Chock-A-Blog, by the one-named author “Tom” is a little bit technology, a little bit entertainment industry, a little bit marketing, and, well, a little bit of everything else that catches Tom’s eye. It’s updated sporadically, but there is a new entry you can be sure it’s always well-written. Chock-A-Blog is where I learned about TXT of the Living Dead, the latest version of Night of the Living Dead as recreated by SMS messages. It also had a nice perspective on the end of the writer’s strike with “What to expect when you’re expecting an end to the writers’ strike”. Add to that a critique of the critiques of the new New Museum. Very varied topics, but informative. Be sure to give Chock-A-Blog a try.

How To Download Youtube Videos, Part 2: Super Easy

2008-03-18T01:33:02Z

How to Get YouTube Videos on your iPod and iPhone from john morton on Vimeo.

If you don’t have time to watch the movie above, just visit Tooble.tv, download the free Tooble software, cut and paste the URL of your favorite YouTube video and presto, your video is in iTunes. That’s super easy.

If you’re on a PC, or just want more flexibility, also check out the earlier post How to Download Flash Video and Play It Back on Your Mac. (And More.). Contrary to the title, you even get some PC how to instructions there as well.

The 3 Buzzword Takeaway of SXSWi 2008

2008-03-13T15:35:00Z

I’m on a plane traveling back from my very first SXSWi. If you’re a geek, and there’s a chance you are if you’re reading SuperGeekery.com, there is a special place and time waiting for you down in Austin next year at SXSWi. Put simply, it’s dorks, nerds and geeks gathering in one place sharing/challenging ideas, rubbing shoulders the Internet famous, and going out drinking and partying like it’s pledge week at a college where the jocks are nowhere in sight.

I’ve had many people tell me this week that the scheduled SXSWi sessions are incidental reasons for attending; the people you meet and become friends with are what make this such a special experience. I feel like I met fewer people than the typical geek but I still managed to meet quite a few people that I hope to keep in touch with. If you’re one of them, thanks for stopping by! I’d love to hear from you, just shoot me an email.

If you didn’t attend though, I want to give you a 3 buzzword take-away of what I’m taking home with me, minus the networking and friend-making.

Buzzword #1: Twitter

This is the second year of Twitter at SXSWi. I followed SXSWi vicariously last year from NYC via the web. Last year was Twitter’s introduction. In one short year, it has become the glue that held this large conference together. It was vital my experience there. What is Twitter? There’s a popular YouTube video floating around that describes it.

My definition? Twitter is a “broadcast” version of instant messaging. You follow people and people follow you to exchange status updates. For example, I “follow” people I want to keep up with in both my personal life and my professional life. Those people update their status regularly, in 140 characters or less, and I receive that update. People who want to keep up with me can follow me as well.

Sometimes these broadcast messages spark public conversations, sometimes private (or in Twitter-speak “direct” conversations) between just 2 people. You can use Twitter via the web, your mobile phone, and a variety of desktop applications. Twitter gets better the more you use it and refine who you follow. Being at SXSW was a great way to meet people I’ve been following for a while in person. If you want to follow me, just visit my Twitter page..

The best summation of it that I’ve read is by Dan Light, who beautifully called SXSWi “mass intimacy”. Check out his post here.

Buzzword #2: Social Media

Since I’m in the ad world, I attended quite a few marketing related sessions and nearly every session mentioned “social media.” I think I heard “viral marketing” mentioned once as passé buzzword. Perhaps “social media” or the “social web” is only simply the phrase du jour, but social media as a concept is the realization of the Internet’s potential and it will only grow. What “social media” is attempting to summarize is a huge bucket of other Internet buzzwords (like viral marketing, blogs, community, MySpace, or Facebook) but it basically means that the little guy has the power and that’s coming at the expense of the big corporate entity dominating the dialog. This is an unstoppable force. The Internet and the voice it’s given to the individual cannot be ignored. Ignore it at your own risk. Check out Get Satisfaction for a great example of the power of social media.

Buzzword #3: Real time

I wouldn’t call “real time” a buzz word, but a buzz concept. The proliferation of real-time media creation was amazing at the conference. I mentioned Twitter as buzzword #1 and it deserves that place, but there were many other examples of real-time documentation happening. Take Francine Hardaway for example, she was “liveblogging” all through the conference using Utterz, Kyte, and of course, Twitter. Her experience at the conference sometimes overlapped mine and her tweets (“tweets” are what individual entries on Twitter are called) gave perspective on events I was witnessing. Sometimes she was somewhere else and I was able to be 2 places at once.

Want more “real-time” experiences? Here are a few more to check out: Qik (regularly used by Robert Scoble and Jason Calacanis to stream video from their phones), Yahoo Live (http://live.yahoo.com), Drop.io (http://drop.io/). There’s also Tumblr.com, which is less about real time, but more about easily posting short hits to a blog. I use it for my hits page here. I’m sure there are many more examples of real time media online and more on the way. There is more emphasis on “now” than ever before.

Overall, SXSW was really fun and inspiring. I hope to see you there next year.

TrueCrypt - How To Protect Your Private Files From Prying Eyes

2008-03-03T23:49:00Z

I thought I’d try something new today. I sometimes talk about software I use, but now I’m going to try showing it as well. I’ll start with TrueCrypt, a free, cross-platform piece of software that obscures your files securely but still leaves you with the ability to retrieve them regardless what type of computer you have.

Consistently Good Emails

2008-02-25T20:10:00Z

Apple gets loads of praise for their products. Thoughtful design and user-centric interfaces make them the best in their class. This level of finish goes beyond iPhones, iPods, and computers. It shows in their marketing of the products as well. When a new Apple television ad is released, it usually has the same qualities and the ads make the rounds of the blogosphere.

But what about the simpler things, like the numerous email messages Apple sends out to customers? Does Apple live up to their own high standards when it comes to the “lowly” email? Of course they do. Here’s a small sample of Apple emails from 2004 to 2007. They are consistently better designed than any other big retailer. These are emails not just for big product launches. They include emails sent for the simple act of registering a product. They all look good. The iTunes emails are the weakest link in the bunch, but as a whole they’re very impressive.

What I think this small collection illustrates is the deep crafting of the Apple brand. No detail is too small to be considered. Nice work, Apple.

Click on a thumbnail to view the larger image.

I’ve noticed how consistently well-designed a few other companies are with their email Both Threadless and Nintendo come to mind. Can you think of others? Take a screenshot and send it to me.

YouTubification of Election 2008, Example #2

2008-02-15T20:11:01Z

Back in January 2007 I did a post here I called The YouTubified Election of 2008. Back then, there was a video from an anonymous source that was an attack ad, modeled after Apple’s 1984 ad, against Hillary Clinton. It didn’t spell doom for the Clinton team, but I thought we’d see more user generated videos for this election. I’ll be the first to admit this prediction didn’t come through great insight. Viral video is an obvious trend. I just find it interesting to see how it’s being used in the election.

Hillary did try to do a viral video parody of the Soprano’s finalle, but it fell flat, so I didn’t mention it here.

Today a friend told me about an inspirational video he’d seen on YouTube for the Obama campaign. Although I’m more in the Clinton camp than the Obama camp, I enjoyed the video. It feels like it has the “right stuff” to make it to viral video stardom. Check it out below.

Taking Cleaner Screenshots with Camouflage

2008-02-14T13:43:02Z

I’m one of those people who has too many icons on my desktop, but you wouldn’t know if from the screenshot above. It would be fair to suggest that I just organize my icons in my documents folder, but that’s just not the way my brain works. Having all my icons on my desktop is how I work. My desktop servers as an inbox for my live projects.

This week I discovered a free little program, Camouflage, by briksoftware. It lets you easily hide a cluttered desktop screen when you’ve got to take a screenshot. I also use it when I hook my laptop up to a projector for a presentation.

Now I’m just a click away from a pristine desktop. And, luckily, I have just one more click back to my organized chaos.

Going to SXSW? Let’s say hello in Austin!

2008-02-07T14:33:59Z

I’m really excited to be going to SXSW Interactive this year. It will be my first at the conference, but not my first trip to Austin. Are you going? If not, why not? Check out some of the interesting panel discussions here. There are also lots of interesting events in the evening. Send me an email if you’re going to be there.

Parody Ads Tell You A Lot About Your Brand

2008-01-25T02:50:00Z

Last year Tom Ford released a fragrance for men that has received less than stellar reviews. A friend showed me the parody of the site. If you want to see them both, do so at your own risk. They are not what I’d call “safe for work”. Click here for the original site. Click here for the parody. I can see why someone did a parody of those Tom Ford ads. They are pretentious and stupid. I think the parody serves as fair warning for any brand with such crappy advertising.

But what happens when a brand listens to their customer and gives them what they want? I’ve got a couple example to share that show what happens when consumers really love a brand/product and take the marketing materials and make it their own. Yes, it’s an Apple example, a brand that almost seems unfair to compare any other to, but it’s worth the comparison if only to show how high the bar is set.

Witness “Hit Me With Your iPhone,” a song composed by a fan and with video remixed from a marketing video on Apple’s site:

Next, take that same video, remix it with a feature suggestion for an improvement to the iPhone. That ”I love you” at the end speaks volumes as to how this brand reaches people.

iPhone Copy and Paste

P.S. iPhone, I love you too.